“With the starts that those guys have had, X in particular, he's had certainly an All-Star-caliber first half, as has Otto,” manager Clayton McCullough said. “He's led the league in hitting really from Opening Day. He's played above-average shortstop. Both those guys, I think, are more than deserving [of] being in that conversation.
“And Liam, what he's done from a production standpoint as a catcher, he's been great. They're all, for me, very much deserving. I hope we can get multiple guys in this year.”
Here are the early cases for that trio, with stats entering Saturday.
2B Xavier Edwards
2026 stats: .307/.391/.462 with 11 doubles, four triples, six homers, 20 RBIs in 64 games
Biggest competition: JJ Wetherholt (Cardinals), Brice Turang (Brewers), Luis Arraez (Giants), Brandon Lowe (Pirates)
Last Marlins second baseman to make All-Star team: Arraez (2023)
Edwards entered Saturday tied with Arraez, Wetherholt and Turang for the highest fWAR (2.5) among qualifying NL second basemen. He is the only one from that quartet to have played in every game this season.
Among that group, Edwards has the second-highest average, the second-highest on-base percentage, the second-most steals (10) and the highest slugging percentage. The 26-year-old’s six homers this season are also more than he had from 2023-25 to begin his Major League career.
According to Baseball Savant, Edwards is also elite in the following metrics: squared-up percentage (35.8%, 95th percentile), whiff percentage (13.7%, 96th percentile) and strikeout percentage (11.8%, 93rd percentile). Like Arraez, he has walked more than he has struck out.
SS Otto Lopez
2026 stats: .331/.361/.468 with 15 doubles, two triples, five homers, 26 RBIs, 10 steals in 63 games
Biggest competition: Elly De La Cruz (Reds), CJ Abrams (Nationals)
Last Marlins shortstop to make All-Star team: Hanley Ramirez (2010)
Lopez entered Saturday third among qualifying NL shortstops in fWAR (2.3), behind De La Cruz (2.7) and Abrams (2.5). Among all qualified Major Leaguers, Lopez ranked second in average (.331), first in hits (82) and tied for first in multi-hit games (24).
The 27-year-old Lopez is the only one of that trio to have a value over 1.0 in all three facets of the game -- baserunning (1.7), offense (11.1) and defense (3.0) -- per FanGraphs. With De La Cruz sidelined by a hamstring strain, that will allow Lopez and Abrams to accumulate counting stats in his absence.