Last week, the great Derrick Goold at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that the Cardinals had received calls from teams interested in catchers Jimmy Crooks and Pedro Pagés and, more intriguingly, first baseman Alec Burleson and shortstop Masyn Winn. The Cardinals have so many catchers right now that the Crooks-Pagés rumors weren’t surprising at all, but the idea that the Cardinals could move two of their regular infielders is more fascinating, even if president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom batted that talk down (for now, at least). Perhaps, then, it is worth exploring the cases for, and against, the Cardinals considering offers on either player. With the obvious caveat that the chances of any trade actually coming to fruition are entirely contingent on what those offers actually contain, let’s take a closer look. |
ALEC BURLESON The case for keeping him: Burleson had the best year of his career in 2026. He led the Majors with 116 RBIs and raised his slugging percentage by 14 points (to .473) while keeping his .343 OBP steady. He hit eight more homers (26), lifted his walk rate by about a percentage point (to 8.1%) and added 7 percentage points to his hard-hit rate (50%, putting him in the 92nd percentile). He also made big defensive strides at first, leading MLB in Statcast’s new receiving metric for first basemen (+8), excelling at picking balls out of the dirt. At this point, Burleson is one of the veterans on this roster, and he’s beloved by his teammates for his big personality and clutch hitting. He also has two more years before he’s due to hit free agency and has shown improvement annually. There is a sense that he could keep getting better. The case for making him available: Bloom and the Cardinals have been explicit about focusing on the long term, and this is where that “two more years before he’s due to hit free agency” is less an opportunity than a ticking clock. Burleson, who turns 28 on Nov. 25, is the oldest regular in the lineup, and a club that’s clearly built around young players may have to decide if he is young enough to be a part of the next great Cardinals team. Most teams in baseball could use a thumping first baseman with excellent fielding skills, and if the Cardinals don’t plan on extending Burleson past 2028, they might want to maximize his value now. That’s particularly true because of logjams at other positions. |
Given the aforementioned glut of catching options, St. Louis may be looking for somewhere else to get Iván Herrera or top prospect Rainiel Rodriguez at-bats, and first base could be where they land. If the Cardinals are not willing to commit to Burleson past 2028, don’t they have to consider flipping him for someone who is more likely to align with their prime window of contention — particularly if that player is a young pitcher who throws hard? MASYN WINN The case for keeping him: Winn, surprisingly, did not win his second straight Gold Glove Award in 2026; the Diamondbacks’ Geraldo Perdomo edged him out in the voting. But you won’t find many people arguing against Winn as the best defensive shortstop in the sport. According to Statcast, he had the third-highest Fielding Run Value in baseball, behind only the Cubs’ Pete Crow-Armstrong and his own middle-infield teammate JJ Wetherholt. (That FRV number, 17, was the exact same one he put up in 2025.) |
Shortstop defense is incredibly valuable for any team, but it’s especially so for a team like the Cardinals that doesn’t have a lot of strikeout pitchers. When Winn missed games late in the season, you could feel his absence at every other position; he makes a difference on every play. Another quiet case for not trading him now: As his hitting has regressed over the last couple of years, you could be doing so at the low point of his value. The case for making him available: Oh, yes: That hitting. In 2024, Winn, at the age of 22, put up a 104 OPS+, making him a slightly above-average hitter, which, combined with his incredible defense, made him an All-Star-caliber player. But Winn hasn’t been able to maintain that level since then, declining to a 92 OPS+ in 2025 and then an 80 OPS+ this year, batting .232 with just five homers in 532 plate appearances. By the end of the season, he was mostly batting eighth or ninth. (Remember: He was the cleanup hitter on Opening Day 2026!) |
|
|
|
MLB MORNING LINEUP PODCAST |
|
|
|
Winn did walk more in 2026 (a career-high 9%), but he also had a career-high 21.8% K/9 rate, which is high for a player hitting for so little power. The Cardinals also potentially have a ready-made replacement in Wetherholt, who filled in excellently when Winn was hurt this year and who played more shortstop than second base during his brief time in the Minors. A little further out, there’s also Jesús Báez, the Cardinals’ No. 15 prospect, who slugged 39 homers this year and reached Double-A. If Winn can’t get his bat going, how long will the Cardinals be willing to wait for him? THE VERDICT Ultimately, this coincides with Bloom’s assessment: The two players should probably stay. Winn is too valuable a defender to lose with this current pitching staff, and if his bat comes around, the Cardinals may want to extend their commitment to him. (He’s currently under club control through 2029.) Burleson seems a clear candidate for an extension, albeit not one as long as Wetherholt’s (which is through 2034). He could be a staple at first base and a bridge to the next decade. But then again: If the Cardinals are overwhelmed with an offer, don’t be shocked. If Burleson and Winn are this valuable to the Cardinals, they’ll be that valuable to someone else as well. It’s a tough decision for Bloom. But aren’t they all? |
|
|
|
FORWARDED FROM A FRIEND? SUBSCRIBE NOW |
|
|
|
To subscribe to Cardinals Beat, visit this page and mark "Cardinals Beat" from our newsletter list. Make sure you're following the Cardinals or that they're checked as your favorite team. |
|
|
|
© 2026 MLB Advanced Media, L.P. MLB trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of Major League Baseball. Visit MLB.com. Any other marks used herein are trademarks of their respective owners.
Please review our Privacy Policy.
You (mlb-newsletters@mlb.com) received this message because you registered to receive commercial email messages or purchased a ticket from MLB. Please add info@marketing.mlbemail.com to your address book to ensure our messages reach your inbox. If you no longer wish to receive commercial email messages from MLB.com, please unsubscribe or log in and manage your email subscriptions.
Postal Address: MLB.com, c/o MLB Advanced Media, L.P., 1271 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020.
|
|
|
|
|